The Wisdom
Crucible

Are Miracles Unscientific?

October 15, 2026

About this teaching

Are miracles unscientific?

The answer depends partly on what we mean by science. Modern natural science is typically limited to natural causes, but does that mean that miracles are incompatible with science, or merely that supernatural causation falls outside of the methodological boundaries of natural science?

In this short reflective episode of The Wisdom Crucible, I consider the distinction between methodological and philosophical naturalism, the limits of scientific explanation, and the biblical relationship between studying creation and knowing its Creator.

This reflection began with a deceptively simple question: If science involves observing reality and reasoning from evidence, why should a real miracle be dismissed as unscientific?

Answering that question required distinguishing between the methods of natural science and philosophical claims about the nature of reality itself. Methodological naturalism restricts scientific explanations to natural causes. Philosophical naturalism goes further by claiming that reality itself is exclusively natural.

Those claims are not the same.

I did not attempt to develop an exhaustive study of miracles, epistemology, or the philosophy of science for this episode. Instead, I wanted to consider how the methodological boundaries of natural science can be mistaken for boundaries upon reality itself — and whether or not natural and supernatural explanations can coexist within our organizing systems of knowledge.

Chapters

Manuscript

Are Miracles Unscientific?

Primary References

1 Kings c. 4 v. 31, 33; Psalm c. 19 v. 1-4, 7-9; Psalm c. 111 v. 2; Proverbs 6:6; Romans c. 1 v. 20

Timothy McGrew, “Miracles,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

National Academy of Sciences, Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science (Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 1998).

National Science Teachers Association, “The Teaching of Evolution” (1997), reproduced in Appendix C of Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science (National Academy of Sciences, 1998).

University of California Museum of Paleontology, Understanding Science, “What Is Science?”

Millard J. Erickson, Christian Theology (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House, 1985), 33–34.

Francis Bacon, The Advancement of Learning, ed. Michael Kiernan (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2000).

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Religion and Science.”

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Scientific Method.” First published November 13, 2015; substantively revised August 8, 2026.

Michael Ruse, Darwinism Defended: A Guide to the Evolution Controversies (Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1982), 322.

Eugenie C. Scott, “Science Tests Its Claims,” PBS NOVA, Intelligent Design on Trial.

Richard C. Lewontin, “Billions and Billions of Demons,” The New York Review of Books, January 9, 1997, 31.

Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion (London: Bantam Press, 2006), 59. ISBN 978-0-593-05548-9.

Richard Dawkins, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What’s Really True (London: Bantam Press, 2011). ISBN 978-0-593-06612-6.

INTRO

Greetings, and welcome to —
The Wisdom Crucible with Jakob McClain —
where you and I engage in the ongoing practice of applying biblical thinking to deepen our understanding of biblical truth.

Are miracles unscientific?

Can they be used as an explanatory cause under a philosophy of science, or are they impossible to consider within the scientific method?

I tend to explain things at length with detail, but this is a short reflection and exhortation — because even a handful of bread and fish given to God can feed thousands.

THE MEAT

For the sake of this discussion, I will define a miracle as an event that exceeds the productive power of nature and is attributable to supernatural agency.

Since I’m speaking from a Christian world-view, that definition ordinarily refers to a detectable event brought about through divine intervention rather than merely an unusual event for which we do not yet know the natural cause.

That means that if an adequate natural cause can reasonably explain the event, I would not infer a miracle merely because the event was unusual.

The National Academy of Sciences (NAS) describes science as “a particular way of knowing about the world”.

Elsewhere in their published media, they also reproduced a statement from the National Science Teachers Association which claims that science is a “method of explaining the natural world” restricted to natural processes and without consideration for supernatural causation.

These statements suggest that science depends on concepts such as empirical standards, logical argument, hypothesis construction, and testing.

One of the NAS reports describes the scientific method as thus: scientists propose competing explanatory hypotheses, derive consequences that can be verified, test those consequences with observations or experiments, eliminate hypotheses that fail, and retain the explanation best supported by the evidence.

Essentially, the process can be simplified to: ask a question, develop hypotheses (also known as proposed explanations or educated guesses) to explain the answer, test with an observation or experiment, and evaluate the hypotheses based on the evidence to draw logical conclusions.

University of California, Berkeley’s Understanding Science, produced by the UC Museum of Paleontology gives a somewhat more sophisticated and practical description that is less limited by the often strictly defined scientific method, but still essentially limits it to the process of testing ideas against evidence from the natural world.

Ironically, I performed that very process without consciously intending to during my initial steps of developing the foundation for this episode.

I asked whether or not miracles are either unscientific or not viable explanatory conclusions within the scientific method. I tested the definitions of miracles, science, and the scientific method, and I evaluated those definitions to determine whether or not there is true contradiction or overlap.

That said, before I appear to treat the modern definition as the only possible meaning of science, it’s worth recognizing that the category has not always been so narrowly defined.

I recently noticed while reading a book titled Christian Theology by Erickson, that he claimed Augustine preferred to describe theology as sapientia, meaning wisdom, over scientia, meaning knowledge, because science dealt with temporal things, whereas theology dealt with eternal things.

The logic of this seemed to be that mere scientific knowledge is lesser because it less directly contributes to things which matter for eternity, whereas theological wisdom is more directly relevant to eternity.

That said, Erickson also suggested that philosophy and theology could be applied as organizing principles for science such that its knowledge can be refined into wisdom.

He went on to say that later, when Thomas Aquinas came along, theology came to be thought of as the “queen of science” because it is more noble than other sciences due to it directly pertaining to God and being derived from his revealed principles similarly to how music is derived from mathematics.

Essentially, theology is derived from a source of certainty that is categorically superior to philosophy derived purely from human reasoning: divine revelation.

If we assert, as Christianity does, that God is the omnipotent and omniscient creator and sustainer of all things, then his direct revelation should give us greater certainty than our own independent philosophical ponderings.

Consider more specifically the scientific method.

There is no single inventor credited with the creation of the modern scientific method, but people tend to refer to Francis Bacon as one of its most influential early architects.

His seventeenth-century program emphasized careful observation, experimentation, guarding against human biases, and reasoning gradually from particulars toward broader conclusions, while figures such as Galileo and Newton contributed other foundational methods.

Bacon, among numerous other historical contributors to science, certainly did not deny spiritual reality as he in fact regarded the study of nature religiously meaningful; although he also wanted natural philosophy and theology kept distinct rather than carelessly mixed together.

So, ideas pertaining to the scope and limitations of the sciences have changed over time.

Some older conceptions were open to considering the pursuit of divine philosophies as a scientific endeavor.

Conversely, common modern philosophies of science which define it as methodologically naturalistic will naturally consider theological matters unscientific by definition.

For those who aren’t familiar with it, methodological naturalism is the convention that scientific explanations appeal only to natural entities, processes, and laws.

It does not itself claim that supernatural realities do not exist.

That claim belongs to philosophical or metaphysical naturalism: the stronger worldview claim that reality is exclusively natural and that there is no supernatural realm.

All that said, there was an encyclopedia entry on the scientific method by the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy in 2015 that was substantially revised on August 8, 2026, which explicitly notes the long-running philosophical dispute regarding the philosophy of science.

The key point of the debate is that even modern philosophy of science has not settled upon one universally accepted method to uniquely define science in every sense of the word.

If we include in our understanding of science the limitation that it is only intended to explain the natural world, and we agree that miracles are effected by unnatural causes, then we can simply say that miracles are unscientific in the sense that science isn’t permitted to consider the supernatural as an explanatory category.

Michael Ruse, a significant 20th-century philosopher of science wrote in Darwinism Defended that “miracles lie outside of science, which by definition deals only with the natural, the repeatable, that which is governed by law.”

Eugenie Scott, physical anthropologist and longtime executive director of the National Center for Science Education, presented essentially the same argument in a transcript available on pbs.org in which she stated, “You can’t control for the effects of God.”

Essentially, this naturalistic methodological presentation of the philosophy of science does not take a side in a science vs. supernatural debate.

It cuts through that false dichotomy to point out that science simply isn’t a process for understanding the supernatural because that’s not what it is designed for within that framework.

That said, even if natural science and theology are methodologically distinct, does Scripture itself treat natural observation and divine revelation as rivals?

Consider the implications of the following 5 passages of Scripture for this discussion.

Psalm c. 19 v. 1-4 and v. 7-9 says,

The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork. Day to day pours out speech, and night to night reveals knowledge. There is no speech, nor are there words, whose voice is not heard. Their voice goes out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world.
The law of the LORD is perfect, reviving the soul; the testimony of the LORD is sure, making wise the simple; the precepts of the LORD are right, rejoicing the heart; the commandment of the LORD is pure, enlightening the eyes; the fear of the LORD is clean, enduring forever; the rules of the LORD are true, and righteous altogether.

End quote.

V. 1-4 present creation as revelatory of God.
His handiwork is identifiable throughout the natural world that He created.

This is part of what’s referred to as general revelation.

V. 7-9 then pivot to special revelation from the Word of God.

So, within this Psalm, God holds together the pursuit of truth through natural observation, a characteristic method of modern science, and the study of special revelation, a characteristic method of theology.

Romans c. 1 v. 20 says that God’s “invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made.”

Clearly, the writer of Romans recognized the potential for study of the natural world to contribute to the understanding of God’s general self-revelation in creation, following the logic of Psalm 19.

Psalm 111 v. 2 says, “Great are the works of the LORD, studied by all who delight in them.”

The “works of the LORD” includes all of the natural world which He created in the 6 days of work from the creation story.

This verse seems to imply that to love the work of the LORD will cause people to study the LORD’s work.

So, much as natural science may contribute to the understanding of God’s general self-revelation, love of God has potential to contribute to the natural sciences rather than being a natural competitor, because passion for God can lead to passionate study of the natural world that He created.

Proverbs 6:6 says, “Go to the ant, O sluggard; consider her ways, and be wise.”

So, not only is the study of nature allowed by God, but it is actually encouraged in order to learn wisdom through his intelligent design of creation and its lesser inhabitants.

Observe, consider, learn.

Is that not also the heart of the scientific method, lacking but a few technically defined steps?

1 Kings c. 4 v. 33 says, speaking of the unmatched wisdom of King Solomon,
>He spoke of trees, from the cedar that is in Lebanon to the hyssop that grows out of the wall. He spoke also of beasts, and of birds, and of reptiles, and of fish.

Solomon, who is described earlier in v. 31 as wiser than all other men, was not merely described as having theological wisdom, but also wisdom of the natural world.

He didn’t merely write 3,000 proverbs and 1,005 songs from his understanding of God. He also understood the plants and creatures of God’s creation — and that was counted as wisdom.

So, while men of natural sciences should not look down on the wisdom of theology, men of theology should not look down on the wisdom of the natural sciences.

If we agree that the scientific process must be limited to the natural as opposed to including the supernatural, or only dependent on and subject to apparent natural laws, then we must simply agree that we have limited the scope of scientific observation and discussion such that it cannot be treated as a means of understanding all aspects of creation without the assumption that all aspects of creation exist only within the realm of the natural world.

Either way you look at it, you can’t undo the reality of a field of knowledge or dimension of creation by redefining terms.

You merely couch them under other categories, or pretend that they don’t exist because they don’t fit in the categories that you recognize as legitimate.

If the common-use definition of science today requires the exclusion of the miraculous, that is a limitation on the explanatory power of the scientific method rather than a philosophically imposed limitation on the causative power of spiritual realities.

In other words, if science doesn’t allow the use of miracles as an explanation because it is limited to describing natural events, then science simply is not equipped to understand all aspects of reality if we assert that creation includes both spiritual and natural aspects, as the Christian worldview does.

Within that framework, using science to try to understand miracles is like trying to use a ruler to measure temperature.

You may be able to tell that something changed if the ruler feels hotter or colder, but you can’t use it to directly observe the specific temperature.

It simply isn’t designed for that, which says nothing about either the reality of the specific temperature or a ruler’s usefulness in measuring distances, which is what it is truly designed for.

So, according to methodological naturalism, I can concede that miracles are unscientific.

However, that is not the same as saying that they are anti-science in the sense that the two concepts are in true existential opposition — that they can’t coexist as means of describing true events in reality.

That would only be true if science could decree that there be no such thing as miracles.

To say that miracles are necessarily excluded from reality by the practice of science seems to me to depend entirely upon the following unproven assumptions:

The scientific process is sufficient to describe all aspects of reality, and the presence of the scientific method precludes the existence of anything which it cannot be properly applied to.

In other words, if something cannot be explained by the human invention of the scientific process, then it cannot possibly exist.

Despite that, some historical and notable thinkers have genuinely crossed the gap from mere methodological naturalism to a philosophical naturalism such as I’ve just described.

Harvard evolutionary geneticist Richard Lewontin famously described an a priori commitment to material explanations, meaning that he was committed to only those explanations which work according to the material world.

In fact, he wrote that “we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door.”

That is not merely a statement about what scientific methodology can investigate. It is an explicit commitment concerning which kinds of explanations will be considered — and with a clear bias!

A methodological framework for the pursuit of truth should not say that “we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door” because that is to exclude a category of cause merely because it is divine.

The only commitment for a truth-seeking framework should be to discover whatever is genuinely true.

Committing oneself to excluding the divine is no more a pure pursuit of truth than committing oneself to ignoring the natural world that was derived from the divine act of creation.

In fact, I would assert that it is worse, because, as I said earlier in regards to ideas associated with Augustine, things which are temporal are lesser than things which are eternal.

To those who like to get nerdy with the terms, I mean that as a teleological argument rather than an epistemological argument.

Regardless, to make the leap from unscientific according to methodological naturalism to impossible or irrational would be a logical fallacy, a non sequitur if you like, because limiting the scope of reality to the standard definition of scientifically described causation seems to arbitrarily exclude what cannot be fully tested by natural means.

Richard Dawkins, whom, last I checked, rejected belief in miracles categorically, made an interesting distinction in The God Delusion.

On the same page, he says that whether events such as the virgin birth, Lazarus's resurrection, or Christ's resurrection occurred is in principle a scientific question, while also saying that miracles “by definition, violate the principles of science.”

Those two statements might sound contradictory to some people, but I don’t think that they necessarily contradict each other.

Miraculous causation may fall outside the methodological-naturalist framework of modern natural science, but the effects of that cause on the natural world do not.

For example, the resurrection of Jesus Christ was a miracle, and yet the claim of the resurrection was supported empirically by the natural observable presence of the once dead and now alive Jesus Christ!

An empirical observation can establish an event or its effects, even if the conclusion of supernatural causation still requires further questioning as to whether an adequate natural explanation is more plausible.

The crucifixion of Jesus Christ is one of the least debated historical facts of his life among scholars.

Along with that is the historical testimony that hundreds of individuals saw him resurrected to life — from individuals, to small groups, and more than 500 people all at once!

One might say that for the ancient contemporaries witnessing the miracles of Jesus Christ, they were proven as objectively as any miracle could be, according to the standard of empirical evidence leading to a suitable conclusion.

They saw his face, heard his voice, and interacted with the man they knew had been slain — even examining the scars from the nails in at least the case of Thomas, the disciple of Jesus.

You only need to prove one genuine miracle to prove miraculous causation as a legitimate possibility.

WRAPPING IT UP

At this point, I think that the clearest answer to the question of whether or not miracles are unscientific is that it depends somewhat on what you understand science to be.

According to the common modern standard of methodological naturalism, supernatural causation is not considered as an explanatory category because natural science restricts itself to the natural world.

I don’t think that we need natural science to change its rules.

It can continue to do what methodological naturalism does well: explaining natural phenomena.

However, I think that there is value in the older, broader understanding of the historical term, scientia, by which we can use science as a broader categorical umbrella for the disciplined pursuit and systematic organization of knowledge derived from appropriate principles and evidence.

Within this broad category, natural science and theological science can remain genuinely distinct without either being expected to exhaust every legitimate form of knowledge.

That way, methodological naturalism can remain the working method of natural science without being confused for philosophical naturalism — the worldview that nothing can exist outside of the natural realm.

Christians have no reason to fear the natural study of creation, and the limits of natural science should not be mistaken for limits upon reality itself.

We can study creation and Scripture honestly and faithfully. This way, we can stop making enemies out of organizational categories of knowledge and truth which all ultimately belong to the same Creator — and if we want to make disciples, we should not ask people to choose between honest observation and faith in the God who made what they observe.

OUTRO

The study and application of God’s Word always blesses and restores me.
I pray that what you’ve heard today draws you to deeper reflection and conversation with the LORD.

In the crucible, wisdom is tempered by truth as transformation is born through Scripture.

If this message encouraged you, you can follow this podcast or find The Wisdom Crucible on YouTube for more reflections and teachings.

The algorithms may run on numbers, but this ministry runs on God’s truth — and my hope is that it kindles your faith in Him.

May the Lord bless you — and within you continually refine wisdom through truth.

Let the natural sciences explore the natural things as an act of worship to the God who created all things.
— Jakob McClain, The Wisdom Crucible

Related teachings